Star letter: ZIS is not a Packard

Published: 11:44AM May 17th, 2012

Dear Classic American,... Your recent Packard feature was interesting and mostly accurate, but two points need correction if I might. The oft-repeated story that during the Second World War ‘Packard sold the body dies for the bigger models to the Russian Government, which turned them into the 1945 ZIS’ is a nice fable, but fable it is.

After the disintegration of the Soviet empire, when it became easier to examine (even acquire) some of these cars, it became quite obvious that the measurements were off. Dies do not make similar panels; they make exact panels. Yes, the overall design was copied from the 1942 Packard line right enough, and some folks swear that the Moscow factory did import hardware assistance of various kinds; but the product was just a copy. Comrade Stalin liked Packards, and if he told you to make something like that, you just did it. The styling of the fenders and other parts of the car were copied from GM. By the way, that was the Soviet Government, not the Russian Government.

As for the assertion that ‘the Curtiss-Wright corporation acquired Studebaker-Packard’, we need to lay that one to rest as well. C-W bought management control; what it acquired were tax credits and some of S-P’s best facilities. The contract was terminated a couple of years later, about the time the Lark was introduced.

George Hamlin
Clarksville, Maryland, USA

George Hamlin is an author of Automobile Quarterly’s Packard and senior editor of The Packard Club’s Packard Cormorant journal, so I think we can safely assume he knows what he’s talking about. Thank you George.

Responses to “Star letter: ZIS is not a Packard”

Current Issue: October 2015

Issue October 2015

1972 Van Nuys: Cruisin' the Miracle Mile

Out of this world: 1957 Mercury Turnpike Cruiser

Win a £400 Rhythm Riot weekend for two!

US car importing: A virgin's guide

Muscle with hustle: 1971 Chevelle SS

Cadillac's king of the hill: 1966 Eldorado


Buy this issue now

• Next issue on sale: October 15, 2015

Issue 294

Issue 294
October 2015

The UK's Number 1 for 27 years

Subscribe and get this issue

Buy it now facebook Sample on-line

Other Letters

March Star Letter: Amazing times!

March Star Letter: Amazing times!

Dear Classic American,
Your feature in the January issue with time-lapse photography of the 1964 Thunderbird was not only very ...

Read More »

February Star Letter: Wot I learned in skool

February Star Letter: Wot I learned in skool

Dear Classic American,
I was interested to read your review of the latest incarnation of the Chrysler 300 (CA ...

Read More »

View all...


Related magazines:

Aviation Classics Classic Bike Guide magazine Motorcycle Sport and Leisure magazine


Find a retailer:

Use our handy tool to find your nearest stockist!
Find your nearest Stockist

Advertising Deadline:

Trade Advertising Deadlines:
November 2015: September 25, 2015
December 2015: October 30, 2015

Book advertising here

Next Issue Out:

October 15, 2015